The Developer Is Late with Act 16: Penalties, Terminating the Contract and What You Can Do in Bulgaria
The Act 16 date has passed. The building looks almost finished, but there are more excuses than documents, while you pay rent — and sometimes mortgage instalments — on a home you cannot live in.
Bulgarian law gives buyers several tools, but they do not combine freely. So the key decision comes first: do you want the home, or do you want your money back? Everything else follows from that.
We have explained what the stages themselves mean — Act 14, the Art. 181 certificate, Act 15 and Act 16 — in our guide to buying new-build property. Here we cover only what to do when the deadline has been missed.
First: which deadline exactly was missed
Re-read the contract and ask: what exactly is the deadline for? Often:
- the deadline is for Act 16 (the commissioning protocol), not for the use permit or certificate of entry into service — or the other way round;
- there is one deadline for handing over possession and a separate one for the notarial deed;
- the deadline is described as "indicative" or comes with an "automatic extension" for delays caused by the authorities or utility providers.
A debtor is not liable if non-performance is caused by something that cannot be attributed to its fault (Art. 81(1) of the Obligations and Contracts Act, ZZD). That is why developers like broadly worded "force majeure" clauses. But delays by their own subcontractors or a lack of financing are, as a rule, not such a cause. Ask in writing which specific event delayed the building, with documents.
Second: where you stand — preliminary contract or notarial deed
Once the building has reached the rough-construction stage and has a certificate under Art. 181 of the Spatial Development Act (ZUT), the units in it can be transferred by notarial deed (Art. 181(2) ZUT). So some buyers are already owners even though the building has no Act 16, while others still hold only a preliminary contract.
The difference is substantial:
- Under a preliminary contract, termination is made by a written notice to the developer, without going to court — under the general rule of Art. 87(1) ZZD.
- Once a notarial deed has been signed, a contract transferring real rights in immovable property can be terminated only through the courts (Art. 87(3) ZZD). That route is slower and rarely the best one.
The delay penalty: the quickest tool
If the contract provides for a delay penalty (neustoyka), it is the first thing you can rely on. A contractual penalty secures performance and serves as compensation for the loss, without the loss having to be proven (Art. 92(1) ZZD). Proving the delay is enough.
A few rules worth knowing:
- A delay penalty is owed on top of performance. You can claim both the home and the penalty for each day or month of delay.
- Larger losses can also be claimed, but those must be proven (Art. 92(1), second sentence, ZZD). Compensation covers the loss suffered and the profit lost, if they are a direct consequence of the breach and could have been foreseen when the contract was made (Art. 82 ZZD).
- A court may reduce an excessive penalty (Art. 92(2) ZZD), and a penalty agreed outside its security, compensation and sanction functions is void as contrary to good morals (Interpretative Decision No. 1/2009 of the Supreme Court of Cassation, General Meeting of the Commercial Chamber).
- The limitation period is three years for claims for penalties and damages under an unperformed contract (Art. 111(b) ZZD). Do not let the claim sit for years.
If the contract has no penalty clause, you are still entitled to damages under Art. 79 and Art. 82 ZZD, but you have to prove the loss and its amount — for example, the rent you paid during the delay.
If you are buying as an individual for personal use, your contract with the developer is a consumer contract. Unfair terms — for example a penalty that runs only in the developer's favour, or a full exclusion of the developer's liability for delay — are not binding on the buyer (Art. 143 and Art. 146 of the Consumer Protection Act).
Set-off: the penalty against the final instalment
The final instalment is usually tied to Act 16 or to the notarial deed. When it falls due, you can set off the accrued penalty against it: where two parties owe each other money, each may set its claim off against the other's (Art. 103 ZZD). Set-off is made by a written statement to the developer with an exact calculation.
Do not just stop paying: if an instalment is due on schedule and you miss it, you may become the party in breach.
Notice with a reasonable deadline, and termination
If you no longer trust the building will be finished, you can terminate. The rule in Art. 87(1) ZZD is that you give the developer a reasonable period to perform, with a warning that once it expires you will treat the contract as terminated. Because the contract is in writing, the warning must also be in writing — ideally through a notarial notice, so the delivery date can be proven.
You may terminate without an additional period if, because of the delay, performance has become useless to you, or if it had to be made strictly on the agreed date (Art. 87(2) ZZD). Termination is not available, however, where the unperformed part is insignificant in view of the creditor's interest (Art. 87(4) ZZD).
Termination is retroactive (Art. 88(1) ZZD): the developer must return what was paid and compensate the loss caused by the breach. If it does not repay after being asked to, it also owes statutory default interest (Art. 86 ZZD).
Note: under Bulgarian case law, when a contract is terminated for culpable non-performance, the delay penalty is no longer owed — only a termination penalty, if one was agreed. So work out what you would lose before sending the notice. It is often better to wait for completion and collect the penalty.
Your right to a refund is only as good as the developer's finances. Check the Property Register for new mortgages or attachments on the land and on your unit — we explain how in our guide to legal checks before buying.
If you want the home: a claim for the final contract
Where the building is already at rough-construction stage but the developer keeps postponing the notarial deed, you can bring a claim to have the preliminary contract declared final (Art. 19(3) ZZD). This is a court route. The statement of claim is registered in the Property Register (Art. 114 of the Property Act), so the judgment can be enforced against third parties who acquired rights after registration — for example, another buyer to whom the developer "sells" the same flat.
You become the owner, but the developer's obligations to finish the building and obtain Act 16 remain, and the delay penalty keeps running.
A practical action plan
- Gather the paperwork — contracts, annexes, payment records, correspondence, announced dates.
- Ask the developer in writing where the building stands — has Act 15 been signed, has the application for a use permit or certificate of entry into service been filed, and when.
- Check the Property Register for new encumbrances and for any other deals involving the same unit.
- Calculate the penalty to a specific date.
- Choose your strategy — wait and set off the penalty, claim the final contract, or terminate.
- Send a written notice with a clear demand and deadline.
If you have a mortgage, tell the bank — drawdowns are often tied to construction stages (see our mortgage guide).
In short
- Read the contract first: which act and which deadline the developer committed to, and what exceptions it reserved.
- A delay penalty is owed without proof of loss, on top of performance, and is time-barred after 3 years.
- Setting the penalty off against the last instalment is the fastest way to collect it.
- Termination returns your money but usually costs you the delay penalty. After a notarial deed it is possible only in court.
- A claim under Art. 19(3) ZZD is registered and protects you against a second sale of the same unit.
If your developer is running late and you are not sure which step is right, call us or visit our office with your contract and annexes. We will tell you plainly what your options are and which one serves you best.
The information is general and indicative and does not replace professional advice.
