Supreme Court ends dispute over Slanchev Bryag AD plot used as the Kotva hotel car park: what the case says about preliminary contracts

Supreme Court ends dispute over Slanchev Bryag AD plot used as the Kotva hotel car park: what the case says about preliminary contracts

Bulgaria's Supreme Court of Cassation has brought to an end the court proceedings over the claims of Garant Turist – S. i V. EOOD to a plot owned by Slanchev Bryag AD and used as a paid car park for the Kotva hotel in Sunny Beach. The joint-stock company announced this on 12 November, BTA reported. Slanchev Bryag AD expects that, now the dispute is finally over, the land will be vacated and a fence erected without the owner's consent will be removed.

What happened

The plot covers about 2,000 sq m in the eastern part of Sunny Beach. According to the company it was used without legal basis for roughly the past ten years.

  • Before taking action, Slanchev Bryag AD carried out a geodetic survey and an ownership check, and in January 2025 sent a notice asking for the land to be vacated voluntarily.
  • In May 2025, with the assistance of the police, the company regained physical possession of the plot.
  • In separate cases, the company says, compensation for use without legal basis was awarded against the same firm: over EUR 20,000 for the plot next to the Kotva hotel and over EUR 45,000 for another property used in 2020–2024.

The other side's position

The hotel's owner, Venelin Tashev, told BTA in May 2025 that he had done nothing unlawful and that he had paid BGN 72,000 (about EUR 36,800) under a preliminary contract for the plot priced at BGN 360,000 (about EUR 184,100). He said he held documents proving the payment and had asked to pay the balance but had been refused. He said at the time that the dispute should be decided by the courts.

On 13 March 2026 the Burgas Court of Appeal upheld the first-instance ruling rejecting the claim to have the preliminary contract declared final. Slanchev Bryag AD said then that, according to the court's reasoning, the contract had not created an obligation to conclude a final sale. Now, according to the company, the Supreme Court of Cassation has ended this dispute as well. The announcement did not cite a case number or the text of the Supreme Court's ruling.

DateEvent
January 2025notice to vacate the plot voluntarily
May 2025Slanchev Bryag AD regains possession with police assistance
13 March 2026Burgas Court of Appeal upholds rejection of the preliminary-contract claim
November 2026company announces the Supreme Court has ended the dispute

Why it matters

The case is part of the wider question of who manages the land and infrastructure in Sunny Beach. In September we reported that the state wants the resort's streets and water network transferred from Slanchev Bryag AD to Nessebar Municipality and ViK Burgas; see our article. For owners of hotels and apartments this is not an abstract dispute: it decides who is responsible for car parks, footpaths and access to buildings.

What it means for buyers, sellers and owners

A preliminary contract is not ownership. Paying part of the price, and even using the property for years, does not make the buyer the owner. A court can declare a preliminary contract final (Art. 19(3) of the Obligations and Contracts Act), but only if the contract genuinely obliges the parties to conclude the sale and contains its essential terms. We explain how to prepare such a contract and protect your deposit in our guide "Deposits and preliminary contracts when buying property in Bulgaria".

If you are buying a hotel or a flat in a resort. Check that the car park, path or green area the seller presents as part of the property really belongs to them. Ask for the cadastral sketch, the title deed, or the lease for the adjoining land. A car park on someone else's land can disappear, and part of the hotel's value with it. We cover the general checks for the area in our guide to Nessebar and its resorts.

If you own land that someone else is using. The case shows the usual sequence: a geodetic survey and ownership check, a written notice, recovering possession through lawful means, and separate claims for compensation for the use. Don't put up fences or remove someone else's structures on your own; speak to a lawyer first.

In brief

  • The Supreme Court of Cassation has ended the dispute brought by Garant Turist – S. i V. EOOD over a plot of about 2,000 sq m owned by Slanchev Bryag AD and used as the Kotva hotel car park.
  • The claim to have the preliminary contract declared final was rejected at first instance and by the Burgas Court of Appeal.
  • In separate cases, compensation of over EUR 20,000 and over EUR 45,000 was awarded for use without legal basis.
  • Before buying in a resort, check the ownership not only of the building but also of the car park and access.

If you are considering buying a hotel, a flat or a plot in Sunny Beach and want us to check the ownership of the property and the land around it, call us or visit the office.

Source: BTA (based on information from Slanchev Bryag AD). This information is general and is not legal or financial advice.

Author

Veni Gospodinova

Veni Gospodinova

Houses & Plots Manager

"There are no unsolvable cases – all it takes is knowledge and perseverance!"