Selling property to a relative below market value in Bulgaria: the tax risks, the heirs and the creditors

Selling property to a relative below market value in Bulgaria: the tax risks, the heirs and the creditors

A parent sells their flat to their son "for a token price". A brother sells his share of the family house to his sister "at the tax valuation", because "that's how it's done between relatives". Deals like these are entirely lawful: the parties to a sale agree the price freely, and a low price does not by itself make the contract invalid.

The risks come from elsewhere: from the tax rules on deals between related persons, from heirs who may argue that the sale hides a gift, and from creditors and the National Revenue Agency (NRA) if the seller has debts. Here is what to know before you sign.

Who counts as a "related person"

Bulgarian tax law uses the definition in § 1, item 3 of the Supplementary Provisions of the Tax and Social Security Procedure Code (DOPK). Related persons include, among others:

  • spouses;
  • relatives in the direct line: parents, children, grandparents, grandchildren, with no limit on the degree;
  • collateral relatives up to the third degree inclusive: brothers and sisters, uncles and aunts, nephews and nieces;
  • relatives by marriage up to the second degree inclusive: for example parents-in-law, sons- and daughters-in-law, and a spouse's brothers and sisters;
  • and, often overlooked, persons one of whom has made a gift to the other.

If the buyer falls into any of these groups, the rules below apply to you.

Tax for the seller: when the price matters

The first question is whether the sale is taxable at all. Selling one home owned for more than 3 years, or up to two properties owned for more than 5 years, is exempt under the Personal Income Taxes Act (ZDDFL). We explain this in detail in our guide to tax when selling property. If the sale is exempt, the agreed price does not change your tax.

When the sale is taxable, a low price can become a problem. For deals between related persons, Art. 77 ZDDFL points to the anti-avoidance rules of the Corporate Income Tax Act: tax is determined on the terms that unrelated parties would have agreed (Art. 15 ZKPO), in other words at market prices. And in a tax audit the burden of proof is on you: under Art. 116(2) DOPK, a person audited over a deal with a related person must prove that it matched the market price, and explain any deviation.

In practice: if you sell a taxable property to a relative below market value, keep evidence for the price, such as an independent valuation, the property's condition or encumbrances. Whether the sale must go into your annual tax return is covered in a separate article.

Tax and fees for the buyer: going below the tax valuation saves nothing

Many assume a lower price cuts the municipal acquisition tax and notary costs. Only up to a point: under Art. 46(2) of the Local Taxes and Fees Act (ZMDT), if the agreed price is lower than the tax valuation, the tax is charged on the tax valuation. The notary fee is also based on the value of the transaction, which in practice is normally not lower than the tax valuation. For the rate in your municipality, see our guide to the property acquisition tax.

There is also a delayed effect. The price you pay becomes your documented acquisition price (Art. 33(6) ZDDFL). If you sell before the exemption periods have run, the taxable gain is calculated from that low price, so the tax is higher than it would have been with a real price.

A disguised gift and the heirs' reserved share

When the price is token or never paid at all, the deal risks being treated as a sham: a sale on paper, a gift in reality. Under Art. 17 of the Obligations and Contracts Act (ZZD), the rules of the concealed transaction (here, the gift) then apply, provided its own validity requirements are met. We explain how nullity and sham deals work in our guide on when a property transaction can be challenged.

Why does this matter within a family? Children, the spouse and, in some cases, parents have a reserved share of the estate (Arts. 28–30 of the Inheritance Act). A gift that encroaches on it can be reduced after the giver's death at the request of those heirs. A sale at a real price does not affect the reserved share. But if an heir proves that the "sale" to a brother or sister was really a gift, it can be treated as a gift.

Proving it is easier than the parties think. Under Art. 165(2) of the Civil Procedure Code, the restriction on witness evidence does not apply to third parties or to heirs when the transaction is directed against them. An heir can use witnesses and any other evidence to show that no price was paid.

Creditors and the NRA: ineffective against them

If the seller has debts, a below-market sale to a relative is one of the first deals that gets examined.

  • The Paulian action (Art. 135 ZZD). A creditor can ask for the deal to be declared ineffective against it. The buyer's knowledge that the creditor is harmed is presumed if the buyer is the debtor's spouse, descendant, ascendant, brother or sister.
  • Public debts (Art. 216 DOPK). Some deals concluded after a public debt is declared or established (or after an audit order, if the audit finds debts) are ineffective against the state and municipalities. This covers deals where what was given significantly exceeds in value what was received, and deals harming public creditors to which a person related to the debtor is a party. In other cases the NRA can also bring a Paulian action, and the related person's knowledge is presumed.

Either way, the property can be sold for someone else's debts even though it is registered to the relative.

Sale, gift or another solution

If the aim is to help a child or someone close, a below-market sale is sometimes the least suitable option. It does not bring the tax advantages of a gift, yet the risk of it being challenged as a gift remains. By comparison, a gift between parents and children attracts no municipal tax under ZMDT. However, a gift can be revoked by a court on the grounds in Art. 227 ZZD, and on a later sale its acquisition price is zero. Other structures are possible too, such as a sale with a reserved right of use. The right choice depends on the goal: settling the inheritance during your lifetime, securing a home for a parent, or helping a child with housing.

How to do it properly

  • Set the price deliberately and be able to justify it with a valuation, the condition of the property or obligations the buyer takes on.
  • Pay for real, by bank transfer. A bank payment is the strongest evidence that the sale is not a disguised gift.
  • Do not put a price in the deed that differs from the real one. It creates risk with the NRA and for the buyer.
  • Check the seller's debts to the NRA, the municipality and creditors before the deal.
  • Talk to the other heirs. Openness today prevents lawsuits years later.
  • Get advice from a lawyer and a tax adviser if the property is taxable or the seller has debts.

In short

  • Selling to a relative below market value is lawful, but relatives are related persons under DOPK.
  • On a taxable sale the NRA can apply a market price (Art. 77 ZDDFL, Art. 15 ZKPO), and you have to prove your price (Art. 116(2) DOPK).
  • A price below the tax valuation does not reduce the buyer's municipal tax.
  • A token or unpaid price can be challenged by heirs as a disguised gift (Art. 17 ZZD, Art. 165(2) Civil Procedure Code, Arts. 28–30 Inheritance Act).
  • If the seller has debts, the deal is exposed under Art. 135 ZZD and Art. 216 DOPK.

How we can help

At Scala Di we help with family property deals, from the market valuation and the debt checks to organising the deal at the notary. Call us or visit our office to talk through your case.

The information is general and indicative and does not replace professional advice.

Author

Plamen Markov

Plamen Markov

Chief Financial Officer

"Success lies in perseverance!"