When a property transaction in Bulgaria can be challenged: void contracts, voidable contracts and the Paulian action — what they mean for buyers and sellers

When a property transaction in Bulgaria can be challenged: void contracts, voidable contracts and the Paulian action — what they mean for buyers and sellers

A signed notarial deed is the most secure form of property transaction in Bulgaria, but it does not guarantee that nobody will ever challenge it. A sale, exchange or gift can be declared invalid on several grounds — sometimes years after signing.

What matters for a buyer is to tell these grounds apart, because they differ in who can bring the challenge, within what time and whether it also affects the next buyer. This guide covers the three that most often affect property: nullity, voidability and the Paulian action. References are to the Obligations and Contracts Act (ЗЗД) unless stated otherwise.

The three types of challenge at a glance

Nullity (void)VoidabilityPaulian action
Legal basisArt. 26Arts. 27–33Art. 135
Who can bring itanyone with a legal interestonly the protected partya creditor of the transferor
Time limitnot subject to limitation3 years (1 year for dire need)limited — act quickly
Effectthe deal never took effectthe deal falls away retroactivelythe deal is invalid only towards the creditor

Nullity: the deal never took effect

Under Art. 26, a contract is void if it breaches or circumvents the law or offends good morals, and also if its subject is impossible, consent is missing, the form required by law is missing, it has no basis (cause), or it is a sham.

With property, the most common cases are:

  • missing form — contracts transferring ownership of real estate must be made by notarial deed (Art. 18); a "sale" with a receipt or an ordinary written contract does not transfer ownership;
  • missing consent — for example a signature made by someone else, or a power of attorney that was never given;
  • sham — the parties sign a sale but actually intend a gift, or state a price in the deed that differs from the real one. Under Art. 17, the rules of the concealed transaction apply if it meets the conditions for validity. Rights acquired in good faith by third parties from the acquirer under the sham agreement are as a rule preserved — except rights in property acquired after the claim of sham was registered.

Nullity is not subject to limitation — anyone with a legal interest can rely on it, even decades later. Time still matters: a buyer who has possessed the property long enough can acquire it by adverse possession — 10 years, or 5 in good faith (Art. 79 of the Property Act).

When the seller is not the owner

A separate case is the sale of someone else's property — for example by a "beneficiary" relying on a forged will. According to prevailing case law, such a sale is not void, but it does not transfer ownership: the buyer cannot receive more rights than the seller had. The true owner can claim the property back from anyone holding it without a legal basis (a vindication claim). We described how such schemes work in practice in our news piece on the attempted sale of a property in Sofia using a forged will.

Voidability: the deal stands until it is challenged

A voidable deal takes effect but can be annulled by a court at the request of the protected party. Under Art. 27, contracts are voidable when concluded:

  • by persons without legal capacity, or by their representative without meeting the requirements that apply to them;
  • by mistake as to essential qualities of the subject (Art. 28);
  • through fraud — deliberately misleading the other party (Art. 29). If the fraud came from a third party, the contract can be annulled only if the other party knew or could not have been unaware of it;
  • under duress — coercion by well-founded fear, including from a third party (Art. 30);
  • by a person who could not understand or control their actions (Art. 31) — for example an elderly owner in poor health;
  • out of dire need on clearly unfavourable terms (Art. 33).

Only the party whose interest the rule protects can seek annulment (Art. 32(1)). The time limit is 3 years, running from discovery of the mistake or fraud, from the end of the duress, from coming of age or the lifting of guardianship, and in all other cases from the date of the contract (Art. 32(2)). For dire need the limit is 1 year from the contract (Art. 33), and the court will not annul it if the other party offers to remove the disadvantage.

A voidable contract can be confirmed — by a written act stating the ground of voidability, or by voluntary performance with knowledge of the defect (Art. 35). Once a deal falls away, each party returns what it received (Art. 34).

Powers of attorney: two special cases

Many deals are signed through an attorney-in-fact. Two risks:

  • if the representative and the buyer collude to the detriment of the person represented, the contract has no effect for that person (Art. 40);
  • if someone acted without authority, the person named as principal can confirm the contract in the same form required for the power of attorney (Art. 42); if they do not, the deal does not bind them.

The Paulian action: when the seller is running from creditors

Art. 135 gives a creditor the right to ask for acts by which the debtor harms them to be declared invalid as against that creditor. The typical case: a debtor with large debts sells or gives their property to a relative so that it does not end up with a bailiff.

The conditions are:

  • the debtor knew of the harm to the creditor;
  • in a deal for value (sale, exchange), the buyer must also have known of the harm. For a gift, the recipient's knowledge is not required;
  • knowledge is presumed until proven otherwise if the acquirer is the debtor's spouse, descendant, ascendant, brother or sister.

The effect is relative: the deal remains valid between the parties, but the creditor can enforce against the property as if it still belonged to the debtor. The invalidity does not affect rights acquired for value by good-faith third parties before the claim was registered — so for the next buyer, what matters is whether they paid a real price and whether the claim was already registered.

A registered claim — what the Property Register shows

Claims for nullity, annulment or rescission of property transactions are registered in the Property Register before the court hears them (Art. 114(a) of the Property Act). If a claim is not registered, the judgment cannot be relied on against third parties until it is (Art. 115). Registered claims appear in the certificate of encumbrances — which is why it should be issued as close to completion as possible. We set out the full set of checks in our guide to legal checks before buying a property.

What to check as a buyer

  1. Certificate of encumbrances — for registered claims, attachments and mortgages, issued immediately before completion.
  2. The chain of title — how the seller acquired the property. A recent gift or sale between relatives is a signal to check whether the transferor has creditors.
  3. The seller's debts — public liabilities, enforcement cases. Ask for a declaration and a certificate.
  4. The power of attorney — notarised, specific to the deal, verified at the notary, ideally recent.
  5. The price — the real price in the deed and payment by bank transfer. A price well below market is used in court as a sign of knowledge of harm or of a sham.
  6. An elderly or ill seller — attending in person, with their family informed.
  7. Co-ownership and inheritance — all co-owners must take part; more in our guide to co-owned and inherited property.

If you are selling or giving property away

If you have significant debts, transferring a property to someone close does not "save" it — the creditor can challenge the deal, and a relative's knowledge is presumed. If you signed under pressure, as a result of fraud or while seriously unwell, the time limits for a challenge are running — see a lawyer straight away.

In short

  • A deal is void without a notarial deed, without consent or if it is a sham — no limitation period, though adverse possession can eventually override it.
  • A deal is voidable for mistake, fraud, duress, incapacity or dire need — only by the protected party, usually within 3 years.
  • The Paulian action makes a deal invalid only as against the creditor; in a sale the buyer is affected if they knew of the harm, while a later good-faith buyer who paid a real price before the claim was registered is protected.
  • A registered claim shows up in the certificate of encumbrances — check it on the day of completion.

If you are buying a property and something in the chain of title worries you — a recent gift, a power of attorney or a court dispute — call us or visit our office. We will go through the documents together before you pay.

The information is general and indicative and does not replace professional advice.

Author

Hristiyan Markov

Hristiyan Markov

Legal Counsel

Solving every case requires in-depth analysis and a professional attitude.