ECtHR rules against Bulgaria over the Orlandovtsi demolitions: EUR 588,000 in compensation and what it means for property owners
The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in Strasbourg ruled on 25 August that Bulgaria violated the right to respect for private and family life and the home (Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights) of residents whose homes in Sofia's Orlandovtsi district were demolished in August 2023. The court awarded each applicant EUR 10,000 in damages and EUR 18,000 in costs – EUR 588,000 in total, Mediapool reported.
What the court found
The judgment does not turn on whether the houses were lawful. According to reports, the applicants held no property rights in the demolished structures that Bulgarian law would recognise. The violation lies in the procedure: the residents had no real opportunity to take part in the proceedings that led to the demolition orders, and no effective way to ask a court to weigh whether demolition was proportionate to their personal circumstances.
According to Mediapool, residents received copies of the orders only after they had been carried out. On 16 June 2023, notices giving 30 days to leave were pinned to doors – unsigned, unstamped and without a named issuer, which made any appeal harder. Attempts by many applicants to stop the demolition through the courts also failed. Demolition began on 9 August 2023, directed by an official of Sofia's Serdika district administration, and around 160 people were left without shelter.
Reports on the judgment also say the court requires Bulgaria to change how such demolitions are carried out.
Not the first judgment of its kind
Bulgaria has lost similar cases in Strasbourg before – the best known being Yordanova and Others v. Bulgaria (2012, concerning the Batalova Vodenitsa settlement in Sofia) and Ivanova and Cherkezov v. Bulgaria (2016, concerning a house built without a permit). The common thread: even where a structure is unlawful, the state must give the people living in it a chance to have an independent court assess whether demolition is proportionate, especially where it is their only home.
What it means for owners and buyers
The ruling does not legalise unlawful buildings. It gives no right to build without a permit and does not automatically halt the removal of illegal construction. What changes is the bar for procedure: orders must be clear, signed by the competent authority, properly served and genuinely open to appeal before they are enforced.
For people living in buildings of uncertain status, or who have inherited one, the practical points are:
- Don't ignore any notice from the municipality, the district administration or the National Construction Control Directorate (DNSK), even if it looks informal. Ask for a written copy of the act and check who issued it.
- Appeal deadlines are short. Acts under the Spatial Development Act are as a rule appealed within 14 days of notification. Talk to a lawyer straight away, not after the deadline has passed.
- Check whether the building may be "tolerated". Some structures built before certain dates and meeting the statutory conditions can be recognised as tolerated and are not subject to removal (§ 16 of the transitional provisions of the Spatial Development Act).
For buyers the lesson is simpler still: the Strasbourg ruling does not make an unlawful building a safer purchase. The compensation is for a procedural breach, not for the lost property. Before any deal, check the building's legality – construction papers, a certificate of use or a certificate of tolerance – and who owns the land it stands on. We recently covered the removal of illegal structures in Stara Zagora's Lozenets quarter, where houses stood on state land outside the regulation plan and could not be legalised. For the full list of pre-signing checks, see our guide to legal checks before buying.
In brief
- On 25 August the ECtHR found against Bulgaria over the August 2023 demolition of homes in Orlandovtsi – a violation of Article 8 of the Convention.
- Each applicant receives EUR 10,000 plus EUR 18,000 in costs – EUR 588,000 in total.
- The problem was procedural: unsigned notices, orders received only after enforcement, and no effective judicial review.
- The ruling does not legalise illegal construction, but it raises the standard for notice and appeal before demolition.
- Buyers should check a building's legality and who owns the land before any transaction.
Questions about the legality of a building you are selling or buying, or have you received a demolition order? Call us or visit our office – we will review the documents and point you to the next step.
Source: Mediapool, on a judgment of the European Court of Human Rights. The information is general and is not legal or financial advice.
