A recorded claim against a property in Bulgaria: what it means for buyers and sellers, and when a lawsuit can bind the new owner
Next to the mortgages and attachments on a property's encumbrance certificate, you will sometimes see an entry reading "statement of claim" (искова молба). Many people take it as a ban on selling. It is not: a recorded claim does not stop a sale. It does warn every later buyer that the property is the subject of a court dispute. If the claimant wins, the judgment can bind the new owner too. Here is what the entry means and how to handle it as a buyer and as a seller.
What a recorded claim is
Certain lawsuits affecting rights in real estate must be recorded in the Property Register at the Registry Office for the area where the property is located. The court will not proceed with the case until the claim has been recorded (Art. 114 of the Ownership Act, ZS). Recording makes the dispute public. Anyone checking the property can see there is a lawsuit and cannot later say they did not know.
A recorded claim is not an attachment (възбрана). An attachment is an interim measure the court imposes on a separate application (Art. 397 of the Civil Procedure Code, GPK). The claimant can ask for both, but recording the claim does not by itself prevent the owner from selling.
Which claims are recorded, and what recording does
| Type of claim (Art. 114 ZS) | Typical example | Effect of recording |
|---|---|---|
| (a) termination, annulment, revocation or nullity of a deed concerning the property | The seller sues to terminate a sale over an unpaid price; a claim to annul a transaction for fraud | The effect is whatever a specific statute provides. Without such a provision, recording only makes the dispute public |
| (b) declaring a preliminary contract final (Art. 19(3) of the Obligations and Contracts Act, ZZD) | A buyer under a preliminary contract sues a seller who refuses to transfer | Real rights acquired and attachments imposed after recording cannot be asserted against the claimant |
| (c) other judgments that replace or establish a registrable deed | A claim to establish that a registrable transaction was made | Real rights acquired by third parties after recording cannot be asserted against the claimant |
The specific provisions for type (a) are in the Obligations and Contracts Act. When a registrable contract is terminated, the termination does not affect rights third parties acquired before the claim was recorded (Art. 88(2) ZZD). In a creditor's actio Pauliana, the invalidity does not affect rights acquired for value by third parties in good faith before recording (Art. 135(1) ZZD).
In practice, the date of recording is decisive. The Civil Procedure Code confirms this: a judgment also binds anyone who acquired the disputed right during the case, except for the effect of recording under Art. 114 ZS (Art. 226(3) GPK). If you buy after the claim is recorded and the claimant wins, the judgment can be enforced against you. The same logic applies when a co-owner sues to buy back a share sold to an outsider (Art. 33(2) ZS). We covered this in our guide to co-owned and inherited property.
The six-month deadline after judgment
When a claim succeeds, the final judgment is noted in the Property Register. The judgment itself gives the claimant six months to do this. Once that period expires, the recording of the claim loses its effect (Art. 115 ZS). If the claim was never recorded, the judgment takes effect against third parties only from the day the judgment itself is recorded. In a claim under Art. 19(3) ZZD, the court will not issue a copy of the judgment until the claimant proves they have paid the transfer costs and the seller's liabilities to the state.
When a claim is dismissed or the case is discontinued, that court decision is noted in the register as well. The property's record then also shows that the dispute has ended.
What it means for a buyer
- Check encumbrances before paying a deposit. The encumbrance certificate shows recorded mortgages, attachments and claims. We describe the full check in our guide to legal checks before buying.
- Ask for the statement of claim itself and the case number. The register entry does not tell you enough. You need to know who the claimant is, what they are asking for, what stage the case has reached and whether there is already a judgment.
- Assess the risk by the type of claim. A type (b) or (c) claim filed before your purchase can cost you the property if it succeeds. A type (a) claim needs a look at its grounds: on termination, rights acquired after recording are not protected.
- Do not rely on the seller's declaration alone. A declaration gives you a claim for damages against the seller. It does not stop a court judgment from taking effect.
- Wait, or require the dispute to be cleared. The safest option is to buy after the case has ended. Another option is for the claimant to withdraw or waive the claim, with the discontinuance noted in the register before you pay.
The reverse also holds: the absence of a recorded claim is not a full guarantee. If a transaction in the chain is void, or someone sold property that was not theirs, the buyer does not become the owner, whatever the register says. That is why the check covers the whole chain of title deeds, not just encumbrances.
What it means for a seller
- The sale is not prohibited, but buyers and banks will see the entry. Expect questions and a longer process, or a wait until the case ends.
- If you are being sued under Art. 19(3) ZZD, selling to someone else does not solve the problem. The new buyer's rights cannot be asserted against the claimant if the claimant wins. You also risk a damages claim from the new buyer. We looked at how this claim works from the buyer's side in our guide to a developer late with Act 16.
- If the claim is unfounded, your defence is in the case itself. When it ends in dismissal or discontinuance, make sure that court decision is noted in the register.
- Tell your agent and the buyer early. A hidden dispute almost always comes out during the checks. When it does, the deal falls apart and the deposit becomes the subject of a new dispute.
In short
- A recorded claim does not prohibit a sale, but it makes the court dispute public.
- The date of recording is decisive. Rights acquired after it generally give way to the claimant (Art. 114 ZS, Art. 226(3) GPK).
- A successful judgment must be noted within 6 months, or the recording loses its effect (Art. 115 ZS).
- Buyers check encumbrances, obtain the statement of claim and case number, and assess the type of claim. Sellers disclose the dispute early.
If the encumbrance certificate for a property you are selling or buying shows a recorded claim, call us or visit our office. We will review the documents with our lawyer and tell you whether, and on what terms, the deal is safe.
This information is general and indicative and is not a substitute for professional advice.
